Most clients whom we work with come to us eager to improve their customer service. Through the use of mystery shopping, clients understand that they can measure their employees’ front-line performance.
It seems simple...and it is: measuring the interaction between the employee and the customer, and rating the customer experience.
It’s what you DO with that information that makes the difference.
Using mystery shopping as a development tool rather than a spying tool reaps many more rewards. Mystery shopping isn’t about “catching people doing something wrong”; rather it’s about “catching employees doing it right” and acting on that information through various performance improvement tactics.
How can you use mystery shop results to improve performance? Start with these 5 tools:
1. Use them for coaching and action planning. Learn more about how coaching and action planning works: You’ve Set Up A Mystery Shopping Program: What’s Next?)
2. Use them as a training tool: block out names on the mystery shop and use the narratives as a platform for discussion with your team, i.e. “What was done well and why?”, “What could have been improved and how?”)
3. Identify best practices from great shop results and share those practices across the organization. For example: A great decision on the front line might be able to be replicated for other front line employees or even with employees that serve internal customers such as in the warehouse.
4. Start a reward system that rewards employees who receive great mystery shop results, and communicate it. Reward and recognition often encourages behavior improvement.
5. Update standard operating procedures (SOP’s) to include any changes to standard procedures that are beneficial as a result of the results gleaned from mystery shops.
Mystery shop results house a treasure trove of actionable data that when used in a productive manner can dramatically IMPROVE your employees’ and organization’s performance…ultimately improving your customer’s experience.
Learn more:
- Download The Mystery Shopping Process
- Download a FREE Mystery Shopping Coaching Guide & Action Plan
- You’ve Set Up A Mystery Shopping Program: What’s Next?
FAQs
1. How does a mystery shopping service improve employee performance?
A mystery shopping service improves employee performance by providing objective, real-time feedback on customer interactions. The results identify strengths, service gaps, and compliance issues. Managers can then use this data for coaching, training, and structured action planning to drive measurable performance improvements.
2. What should you do with mystery shopping results?
After receiving mystery shopping results, review them promptly, meet with employees individually, and create an action plan. Use the findings for coaching, team training discussions, best practice sharing, and performance recognition programs. Acting quickly on feedback ensures lasting improvement.
3. Is mystery shopping meant to discipline employees?
No. A professional secret shopper service is a development tool, not a punishment tool. Its purpose is to reinforce positive behaviors, identify training opportunities, and improve service consistency. When positioned correctly, mystery shopping builds employee engagement rather than fear.
4. How can mystery shopping results be used in team training?
Managers can remove employee names and use mystery shopping narratives in team workshops. Discuss what was done well, what could improve, and how interactions align with brand standards. This approach turns your mystery shopping service into an ongoing training resource.
5. What business metrics improve with mystery shopping?
When companies consistently act on insights from a mystery shopping service, they often see improvements in:
-
Customer satisfaction (CSAT)
-
Net Promoter Score (NPS)
-
Sales conversion rates
-
Employee engagement
-
Service consistency
Used strategically, mystery shopping drives both customer experience and revenue growth.
-
